Cohesion and disintegration in the Russian army, part four: the experience of war

Brian M Downing  The view presented here in parts 1-3 is that the Russian army is flawed. Some 25% of its troops are poorly-trained and indifferently-motivated conscripts who do not fit well with dedicated regulars. Promotions from field grade to general staff are often based on political loyalties not professional Read More …

Cohesion and disintegration in the Russian army, part three: harsh discipline

Brian M Downing  Discipline is essential to armies. It can be achieved through able and perhaps even personable leaders, an unquestionably just cause, pay incentives, or corporal punishment. Most armies have all four.  The Russian army’s leaders are of dubious quality, pay is low, and there hasn’t been a just Read More …

Cohesion in the American military from WW2 to the present

Brian M Downing  But we in it shall be remembered –  We few, we happy few, we band of brothers. – William Shakespeare, Henry V We’re stuck over here God knows how long, just waiting and sweating it out, and finding out things about yourself that, by God, it don’t pay Read More …